Skip to main content

Blog 5: Troublemakers (Argument)

Troublemakers written by Shalaby was written to put spotlight on the mismarking of 'misbehaving' children in the classroom. Shalaby advocated that children, no matter your background, have the right to freedoms. These freedoms included but weren't limited to the right to safety, the right to be treated as a human being, and the right to language and land. With this belief that many will agree with, she argues that education is one of the primary freedoms that children deserve to have.
     Shalaby explains that as well as education being a primary freedom, it also provides kids with a place to learn and exercise the freedoms that they undeniably deserve. However, schools tend to push back on this, creating a system where children are expected to be silent and obey social order rules rather than challenge them. All schools across funding gaps fail to teah their students their freedoms. While some very wealthy schools better establish individuality, students are still impacted by the tendency of grouping students. This grouping also effects these students when it comes to the violence they see, further taking away these freedoms they weren't shown they really obtained. These students are growing up to believe that only some deaths are tragic, only some lives matter, and only a few deserve relief from suffering. This acceptance sprouts from their lack of challenging systems and norms due to the punishment and shame that they would receive in return for it. Students are taught from a very young age that acts, even in the name of justice, will be punished.
     Shalaby discusses four students throughout the story, all with differing backgrounds, but all being marked as the troublemaker, impossible to work with, and the disturbed, by their teachers. Shalaby is attempting to turn the story over for these students and bring attention to the system being the issue. Teachers are taught that less-than-human punishments (such as humiliation, removal, and separation) are the only effective way to manage your classroom when students 'act out'. These students who are looking for change are instead being pushed away and having their education taken away as a punishment.     
    Shalaby used a student she had named Anthony, who loved learning but hated the schools restrictions that came with it. Anthony would, as a result challenge these restrictions with his behavior; being aggressive to other students, leaving the room, and other actions that come off to be disruptive. She felt that her age and qualifications gave her the power over him (which is a common thought shared by teachers) and that his success was dependent on his accepting that he was the one without power. However, Anthony's resistance continued. 
     Many teachers have struggled with this pushback from students, more than half of them saying their classes have a hard time falling into the school routine. A large portion of teachers who resigned marked behavior as a primary reason for their leave. Students as young as five-years old are expected to understand and accept social control when they are unable to. Schools demands are impossible for growig children who are naturally curious and develop at their own pace. Adults are very quick to correct children on the 'wrong behavior' that sprouts from an adults mind (who have accepted this power dymanic of adult-child) that covers kids natural desires.
     Teachers are dismissing the reasons as to why a student may behave in the manner that they do, but Shalaby aims to draw attention to it. She used a notible metaphore of these students being the canaries sent into the mines. She is hoping that people will be able to understand that these students aren't troublemakers, they are instead being the sacrifies for change so others don't have to be. They are ruthlessly pointing out the flaws in the system in hopes that somebody, anybody will listen to their cries and make a change for students. Here is a video on a school in Virginia and the system they created to improve behavior rather than punishing students. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tgP78z0WupM&t=237s

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Blog 1: Alan Johnson and SCWAAMP (Argument)

      While reading Johnsons  story,  Privilege, power, and Difference  he is showcasing his argument of power struggles that are in our society.  He discusses how factors such as race, gender, and social classes can all vary a persons life experiences.  Johnson points out that the only way to truly work towards a solution for these injustices would be to rewire how we react to being told we have a privilege.  We often times take being told we're privileged as an attack, needing to defend ourselves.  Rather than taking it as a personal attack, Johnson is more so drawing attention to the fact that, yes, in order for someone to have a privilege, it is often at the expense of others.  He argues that having privilege isn't wrong, but the issue lies more with not understanding that you have it in the first place.     It is often pushed in this story the idea of denying privilege in turn invalidates those who are disadvantaged. ...
1 comment
Read more

Blog 6: Kohn (Argument)

Kohn's chart and Culturally Relevant Prodigy video is arguing for the need to understand a students culture and their individuals needs to have a flourishing classroom. When trying to incorporate culturally relavant prodigy, the culture factor is often forgotten about. There is a need to focus on how to connect students to their education with the use of their beliefs, personal experiences, and ideas. Students come into the classroom with their own experiences and schools need to be able to use these as a way to effectively education. These students are trying to learn through the schools cultural lens and if they are unable to personally connect themselves to it, their ability to learn new information will be restricted.        Race and ethnicity often times is conflated and will misdirect schools and teachers from understanding what a student needs. This will continue to put these students in a system with a one size fits all method that is known to be ...
1 comment
Read more

Blog 4: Ethnic Studies (Argument)

     Sleeters review;  The Academic and Social Value of Ethnic Studies , is arguing that students who are given opportunities to learn about their diverse backgrounds are evidently more interested and engaged in the classroom.  She discusses her experience with a student named Carlos, who although didn't have great grades in high school was driven and enjoyed learning in the classes that were centered around his culture.   After he discovered his love for learning about his culture, he was an avid reader of Mexican vaquero culture and completed two years of community college.  Sleeter explained that the incorporation of Chicano studies had the same impact on many of her students as it did for Carlos.       The integration of Euro-American studies in schools is often overlooked by not only the education system but as well as parents.  Many would assume that students would be able to connect themselves to material that was alread...
1 comment
Read more