Skip to main content

Blog 1: Alan Johnson and SCWAAMP (Argument)

     While reading Johnsons story, Privilege, power, and Difference he is showcasing his argument of power struggles that are in our society.  He discusses how factors such as race, gender, and social classes can all vary a persons life experiences.  Johnson points out that the only way to truly work towards a solution for these injustices would be to rewire how we react to being told we have a privilege.  We often times take being told we're privileged as an attack, needing to defend ourselves.  Rather than taking it as a personal attack, Johnson is more so drawing attention to the fact that, yes, in order for someone to have a privilege, it is often at the expense of others.  He argues that having privilege isn't wrong, but the issue lies more with not understanding that you have it in the first place.

    It is often pushed in this story the idea of denying privilege in turn invalidates those who are disadvantaged.  There is emphasis on what is 'standard' and how that has an impact on what is seen as privilege.  In comparison to the SCWAAMP reading, it is questioned how maleness and also whiteness is valued in our culture.  Johnson, similarly explains how he understands that he has certain protections due to being a white male.  An anecdote that he shares is an experience he had with his friend, an African American Woman.  He explains how if he was to go into a store he would likely be helped sooner than her, or that he wouldn't be questioned if he was to write a check as much as she would.  Seeing how he fits these ideals based solely off of appearance, he explains that it does in fact give him a privilege, while she would be the disadvantaged group.  Even with this, there is still a feeling of guilt and struggle to bring up the issues at hand.  He stresses how her misfortune is in a way directly connected to his fortunes.  

    While it is important to understand when you have a certain privilege, it is also important to acknowledge that just because somebody obtains one privilege, doesn't mean that the possess all of them.  Personally, I can look at the SCWAAMP reading and see how there are some standards and values that I do have.  Being straight, white and American are all advantages that I can say I was born into.  However, there are still disadvantages that I could have, one being a woman.  Even though that value doesn't apply to me, it doesn't take away the privileges that I do have.  

    Seeing how Johnson describes his own experiences and point of view on privilege and power, it emphasizes the need to let go of lingering guilt and defensiveness that comes with having a privilege.  Being able to do so is the most crucial step in being able to actually equalize power.  While it can be a difficult conversation, it is essential to discuss it in a manner that will push people to be more understanding and motivated towards this change.  

Diversity Wheel - Welcome to CCLI (Cultural Competence Learning Institute)

Here is an example of a cultural diversity wheel and all of the different facts that can go into ones individuality.  Any of these factors can be perceived as being a privilege or disadvantage, some individuals may obtain more of these factors than others. 

This is an article that briefly discusses the ways to talk about having privileges and additionally, unfamiliar practices that I found to be interesting that gave people privilege. 

https://hbr.org/2021/08/talk-about-privilege-at-work

Comments

  1. This analysis of Johnson's Privilege, Power, and Difference really resonates with me. You highlight his key point that recognizing privilege shouldn’t be seen as a personal attack, but as a chance for growth. It’s insightful how you connect this to SCWAAMP, emphasizing that privilege can be nuanced; while some advantages exist, everyone faces unique challenges.

    I also appreciate your point about the common struggle with guilt over privilege. Understanding it can lead to more meaningful conversations about equality. Letting go of defensiveness is essential for fostering genuine dialogue, and your reflections show why this discussion is so important. Thanks for sharing these thoughtful insights!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Blog 6: Kohn (Argument)

Kohn's chart and Culturally Relevant Prodigy video is arguing for the need to understand a students culture and their individuals needs to have a flourishing classroom. When trying to incorporate culturally relavant prodigy, the culture factor is often forgotten about. There is a need to focus on how to connect students to their education with the use of their beliefs, personal experiences, and ideas. Students come into the classroom with their own experiences and schools need to be able to use these as a way to effectively education. These students are trying to learn through the schools cultural lens and if they are unable to personally connect themselves to it, their ability to learn new information will be restricted.        Race and ethnicity often times is conflated and will misdirect schools and teachers from understanding what a student needs. This will continue to put these students in a system with a one size fits all method that is known to be ...

Introduction

  Hello! My name is Olivia and I'm 19 years old.  This is my second year at RIC and I'm majoring in elementary special education.  I have 2 pets, a cat named Oliver and a dog named Millie.  I've lived in Rhode Island for all of my life   I work at Subway three days a week and I've been there for around 2 years now.  Luckily, my friend helped me to get the job and I've enjoyed becoming close with the others there.  In my free time I'm usually with friends, reading or listening to music. This is my friend Sara who I've known since we were in kindergarten.  She is also an education major and has been very helpful to my countless questions when I changed my major.  We spend a lot of time together crafting different things and just wandering around talking about anything and everything.    When first transitioning into college I was unsure on what I wanted to major in, changing it several times in my first semester alone.  I knew th...